How to Make a Vegan Brandy Sauce for Christmas Pudding
- 19 Nov, 2026
A Christmas pudding without something poured over it feels unfinished, and for a growing number of tables that something now has to be dairy free. The good news is that brandy sauce is one of the easiest festive sauces to make without milk or cream. With the right plant drink and ten minutes at the hob you get a glossy, pourable sauce that nobody will treat as the "special diet" option.
What Brandy Sauce Actually Is
It helps to know what you are copying. A classic British brandy sauce is a sweet white sauce: milk thickened with either a roux (butter and flour) or cornflour, sweetened with sugar and finished with a splash of brandy. It is served warm and poured, which makes it different from brandy butter (butter, sugar and brandy beaten together and served cold in spoonfuls) and from custard, which is traditionally thickened with egg yolks.
That matters because a white sauce has no eggs to replace. Swap the dairy milk for a plant drink and the butter for a plant-based block or spread, and the method stays exactly the same. You are not fighting the recipe, only choosing ingredients that behave well when heated.
Choosing the Plant Drink and Fat
The drink makes or breaks the sauce. You want something with body and a neutral flavour, and it must be unsweetened, because you will be adding sugar yourself and sweetened drinks make the sauce cloying.
- Oat drink: the best all-rounder. It is naturally creamy and slightly sweet, and its starch helps the sauce thicken smoothly.
- Soy drink: the richest and closest to whole milk. A good choice if you want a fuller sauce.
- Almond or rice drink: thinner and lighter. They work, but the sauce ends up less creamy, so add a splash of plant cream at the end.
- Coconut drink: avoid it here unless you want the coconut to come through alongside the brandy.
Our guide to choosing a dairy-free milk goes through how each type behaves when heated. For the fat, a firm plant-based block gives a cleaner result than a soft tub spread, which contains more water. If you want an extra rich finish, stir in a little plant-based double cream such as Elmlea Plant Double once the sauce has thickened.
The Recipe: Roux Method
This makes enough for six portions over Christmas pudding. It takes about ten minutes and uses one saucepan and a whisk.
You need: 30 g plant-based butter, 25 g plain flour, 500 ml unsweetened oat or soy drink, 50 to 60 g caster or light brown sugar, 3 tablespoons brandy, a pinch of salt and, if you like, half a teaspoon of vanilla extract.
- Melt the plant butter in a saucepan over a low heat. Stir in the flour and cook for 2 to 3 minutes, stirring all the time, until the raw flour smell is gone. Do not let it brown.
- Take the pan off the heat and pour in about a quarter of the cold plant drink. Whisk until completely smooth, then add the rest in two or three goes, whisking each time.
- Return the pan to a low to medium heat and keep whisking until the sauce thickens and just bubbles, about 5 minutes. Keep the whisk moving across the bottom and into the corners, where it catches first.
- Turn the heat right down, stir in the sugar, salt and vanilla, and let it simmer gently for a minute until the sugar has dissolved.
- Take the pan off the heat and stir in the brandy. Taste, and add a little more sugar or brandy if you want.
The sauce should coat the back of a spoon but still pour easily. It thickens as it cools, so it is fine if it looks a little thin in the pan.
Gluten free? Use cornflour instead
Replace the roux with about 3 tablespoons of cornflour. Mix it to a smooth paste with a few tablespoons of the cold plant drink, whisk that into the rest of the drink with the sugar, and bring it slowly to a simmer, whisking constantly until thick. Stir in the plant butter, then the brandy off the heat. Cornflour gives a slightly more translucent, glossy sauce, which some people prefer.
Common Problems and How to Fix Them
- Lumps: usually caused by adding all the liquid at once or by letting the pan get too hot before it is smooth. Pass the sauce through a sieve, or blitz it briefly with a stick blender.
- Too thick: whisk in more plant drink a tablespoon at a time over a low heat.
- Too thin: simmer it gently for a few more minutes. If that is not enough, whisk a teaspoon of cornflour into a little cold drink and stir it in.
- A skin on top: press a piece of baking parchment onto the surface while it waits, or keep it warm in a jug and give it a stir before serving.
- Separation: some plant drinks can split if they boil hard for a long time. Keep the heat moderate and stop once the sauce has thickened.
Brandy, Alcohol and Who Is at the Table
Because the brandy goes in at the end, most of the alcohol stays in the sauce. A widely quoted table from the US Department of Agriculture estimates that about 85 percent of the alcohol remains when it is added to a hot liquid and then taken off the heat. So treat brandy sauce as an alcoholic sauce: not for children, anyone who is pregnant or anyone who avoids alcohol for any reason, including drivers.
The easy solution is to split the batch before step 5. Flavour one half with brandy and the other with vanilla, a little finely grated orange zest and a pinch of nutmeg or mixed spice. Serve them in clearly labelled jugs so no one picks the wrong one.
Most brandies are made without animal products, but some drinks are fined with ingredients such as gelatine or egg white. If a strict vegan guest is coming, check the producer's information or a vegan drinks database such as Barnivore before you buy.
Short on Time: Shop-Bought Options
Christmas Day is busy, and there is no shame in a ready-made sauce. Several supermarkets now sell plant-based versions in the weeks before Christmas, and they usually only need warming. The M&S Plant Kitchen Oat Brandy Sauce is one example of a vegan brandy sauce: it is made on an oat base and can be heated on the hob or in the microwave, and it is meant for Christmas pudding and mince pies. Seasonal products like this tend to disappear from shelves soon after Christmas, so buy early if you want one.
Whichever you choose, read the label for allergens. Oat-based products are not always certified gluten free, and some vegan sauces and creams contain nuts or soy.
Making It Ahead and Serving
Homemade vegan brandy sauce keeps covered in the fridge for up to three days, so you can make it on Christmas Eve. It will set quite firm when cold. Reheat it gently in a saucepan, whisking in a splash of plant drink until it pours again, and do not let it boil hard. Check the pudding itself too: traditional Christmas puddings can contain butter or beef suet, so a vegan sauce only helps if the pudding is also plant based.
If you are cooking for a mixed table this year, make the roux version once in the next few weeks as a trial run. It takes ten minutes, it tells you whether you prefer oat or soy, and on the day you can make it without looking at the recipe.
